Wrexham vs Barnsley Prediction: Can Welsh side find another win?

We’ve got a major League 1 clash coming our way on Tuesday night as Wrexham host Barnsley at the Racecourse Ground (19:45, Sky Sports+). Phil Parkinson’s side are currently sitting pretty in second place, after a seriously impressive start to the new campaign. 

They host Barnsley, who are currently occupying the final play-off position in sixth. So with both of these teams targeting promotion this term, who will come out on top in this midweek clash? Below you can find my Wrexham vs Barnsley prediction featuring team news and betting tips.

Team News

Wrexham could name an unchanged XI heading into this one and with goalkeeper Arthur Okonkwo out with an injury, Callum Burton will continue in goal. Ollie Palmer looks likely to lead the line again with Paul Mullin likely to have to settle for a place on the bench once more after a disappointing campaign. The experienced forward only has one goal to his name this season and as a result has lost his starting spot.

Elliot Lee is the star in the number 10 position, while Matty James, George Dobson and Oliver Rathbone make up a combative yet quality central midfield. James McClean will be able to bomb forward from left wing-back, while Ryan Barnett has been excellent on the right, creating seven big chances in League 1 this term. 

Adam Phillips has been class this season in the heart of Barnsley’s midfield, with six goals to his name already and he will start again despite missing the crucial penalty against Bristol Rovers last time out. Darrell Clarke chose not to rotate his side at the weekend, which he may come to regret with two tough fixtures to come in the league. 

Marc Roberts should provide a goal threat from set pieces, while Davis Keillor-Dunn and Stephen Humphrys will continue their partnership up front. Barnsley will once again need a strong performance from Luca Connell in midfield. 

Wrexham vs Barnsley Odds

Wrexham are priced at 13/10 to win this game, giving them an implied win probability of 43%. Barnsley meanwhile are priced at 2/1, a draw is 5/2 and over 2.5 goals is 4/5. BTTS can be backed at 8/13 while Mullin is the favourite to open the scoring at 11/2. 

Under 2.5 goals @ 10/11

Wrexham’s defensive record leads me to believe that this will be a relatively low-scoring affair, despite the fact that these are two of the promotion contenders in League 1. The Welsh side have only conceded four goals at home, and 11 goals in total from 17 games in 2024/25, with their back three well protected by a hard-working midfield in front of them. 

I think a key to their defensive success has been the ability to go long when under pressure, with Palmer a wonderful target man in League 1. He can compete for the ball and win knockdowns, while Parkinson has got his side working hard on and off the ball. Barnsley have been good for a goal so far this term, but I think they will struggle against this Wrexham side. A tight affair is expected in North Wales.  

Wrexham to win to nil @ 16/5

Wrexham have been incredibly good so far this season, especially at home. Their record in Wales reads: played nine, won eight, drawn one. Amazingly, they’ve scored 20 and conceded just four at the Racecourse this season, while they have now kept five clean sheets in a row in all competitions at home. I’m backing them, even against a decent Barnsley side to keep another one, given their defensive solidity in their 3-5-1-1 formation.

The Tykes had 30 shots against Bristol Rovers in their FA Cup match, but failed to find the net before losing on penalties. They’ve failed to score in two of their last three matches and so I’ll back a Wrexham win to nil at big odds. 

Acca Flex: Place a pre-match 5+ leg Football accumulator and get a CASH bonus up to 100% if all of your selections win or your money back as CASH if one leg lets you down.

You can read all our latest Football Betting Tips at our dedicated Betfred Insights content hub.